Many Ontario residents still pay for care out of their own pocket, even with public health coverage. In fact, about 32% of Ontario’s total health spending is financed privately, either through out-of-pocket payments or private insurance premiums.
That’s why health insurance is so important. Costs for things like prescription medication, dental work, vision care, and other services like message therapy can mount up quickly. A strong plan helps with everyday costs and makes it easier to plan for health care costs.
This guide lists the top five health insurance companies in Ontario. Look into what each provider has to offer and what you should check before you buy to get a plan that fits your demands and budget.
Ontario’s Top 5 Health Insurance Providers
Choosing health insurance in Ontario can feel overwhelming at first because many plans look similar on the surface. Most of the time, the only major distinctions are what is covered, how much you may claim each year, and how easy the provider makes the whole thing.
Here’s a quick side-by-side look at the top options.
| Insurance Provider | Highlights | Coverage flexibility | Application experience |
| PolicyMe | Online health and dental plans with straightforward pricing | Simple plan options with practical coverage | Fully online and quick to apply |
| Sun Life | Established insurer with a wide range of personal plans | Multiple coverage levels and add-ons | Online options + advisor support |
| Manulife | Popular personal health plans with strong availability | Tiered plans for different needs and budgets | Easy online tools and guided setup |
| Ontario Blue Cross | Trusted for health coverage and travel-related protection | Flexible benefits depending on the plan | Clear application process |
| Green Shield Canada | Strong individual coverage for everyday health costs | Several plan tiers with different limits | Easy plan comparison and signup |
Let’s break down each provider in detail, including what they cover and what to watch for when choosing a plan in Ontario.
1. PolicyMe
PolicyMe Health Insurance Inclusions
- Prescription drugs: 70% covered (up to $500–$700 per year)
- Dental: $500 per year (Economic) or up to $1,200 per year (Advanced)
- Vision: $260–$500 every 2 years
- Paramedical: up to $600–$1,000 per year total
- Mental health: $500–$1,300 per year
PolicyMe stands out in Ontario because it focuses on the most common expenses people usually pay for themselves, like prescriptions, dental work, vision care, and everyday health services that aren’t covered under public health care for most adults.
It also keeps things simple. The plans are easy to compare, the pricing is straightforward, and the application process is fully online. For many people, that’s a big deal, since shopping for coverage can feel confusing and time-consuming.
Another reason it ranks #1 is the potential savings. PolicyMe estimates its Guaranteed Issue Classic plan can save the average Ontario household around $1,680 per year across drugs, dental, vision, paramedical, and mental health expenses.
Overall, PolicyMe earns the #1 spot because it balances real everyday coverage with a simple buying experience. The benefit limits are clear upfront, the plans cover the categories most Ontario residents actually spend on, and the online setup makes it easy to get insured.
| Pros | Cons |
|
|
2. Sun Life
Sun Life Health Insurance Inclusions
- Prescription drugs: 60% to 80% covered (depending on the plan)
- Dental: 60% coverage for preventive dental (up to $500/year)
- Vision: $250–$300 every 2 years
- Paramedical: $25/visit (up to $250/year per practitioner)
- Mental health: $35/visit (up to $500/year)
Sun Life is one of the most established insurance providers in Canada, and it’s a strong choice for Ontario residents who want multiple plan levels to choose from.
Instead of giving a single set of coverage, SunLife lets people choose the level of coverage that fits their budget. What makes it great is that it covers prescription drugs, and higher levels cover up to 80% more than the normal yearly limits.
Sun Life also includes everyday benefits like vision care and paramedical coverage, which helps reduce the regular expenses that tend to creep up throughout the year. With its clear plan levels and strong drug coverage choices, Sun Life stands out as a whole.
| Pros | Cons |
|
|
3. Manulife
Manulife Flexcare Plan Inclusions
- Prescription drugs: up to 90% coverage (annual max varies by plan)
- Dental: up to 100% coverage (up to $1,500/year on higher plans)
- Vision: $150–$250 every 2 years
- Paramedical: $300–$400 per practitioner/year
- Emergency travel: up to 9-day coverage on some plans
Manulife is a strong pick for Ontario residents who want more control over how their plan is built. Its Flexcare lineup is designed around choice, with different plan levels that let you scale coverage up or down depending on what you actually want covered.
Where Manulife really shines is the range on its higher-tier options. Having access to stronger prescription coverage and higher dental limits can make a big difference for people who use those benefits regularly, especially when costs start piling up across the year.
All things considered, Manulife shines out because it offers Ontario consumers flexible plan options with competitive coverage limitations in the regions where people spend the most money.
| Pros | Cons |
|
|
4. Ontario Blue Cross
Ontario Blue Cross Plan Inclusions
- Core coverage areas: Prescription drugs, dental, and vision (including eye exams)
Ontario Blue Cross is a familiar choice in Ontario, mainly because it offers the core benefits many people shop for first: help with prescriptions, dental care, and vision-related costs. That makes it a practical option for anyone trying to reduce the routine expenses.
What makes Ontario Blue Cross stand out is accessibility. It offers no-medical plan options available up to age 74, which can be a big plus for older adults who want coverage without going through a long medical approval process. This also makes it easier for people who have been turned down elsewhere to still explore private coverage.
As a whole, Ontario Blue Cross is a good option for Ontario residents looking for a well-known provider, fundamental health benefits, and a more supervised enrolment process.
| Pros | Cons |
|
|
5. Green Shield Canada
Green Shield Canada ZONE 1 (Basic Plan) Inclusions
- Vision: $150 per person every 2 years
- Paramedical: $40 per visit, up to $400/year
- Mental health: up to $400/year (combined)
- Telemedicine: 4 virtual visits per year (24/7 access)
- Emergency travel: 15 days per trip (up to $5,000,000/year)
Green Shield Canada is a strong option for Ontario residents who want everyday coverage that focuses on common, predictable costs. Even at the basic level, it includes benefits that many people actually use, which can help reduce spending throughout the year.
It also offers real value for people who travel. A basic plan that includes 15 days of emergency travel coverage per trip, up to $5,000,000 per year, is a meaningful benefit, especially for anyone who takes short vacations or visits family outside Ontario.
All things considered, Green Shield Canada is an appealing choice if you’re looking for simple coverage, practical extras like telemedicine, and benefits that support daily medical needs.
| Pros | Cons |
|
|
How to Choose the Right Health Insurance Plan in Ontario?
Picking a plan isn’t just about choosing the one with the lowest monthly cost. In reality, what counts is whether the benefits are worth the money and the limits are high enough to make the coverage worth it.
Step 1: Pick coverage based on real needs
Start with the areas where money usually goes first. For many Ontario residents, that’s prescription drugs, dental care, vision expenses, and services like physiotherapy. A plan that covers the right categories will always feel more useful than one with benefits you barely use.
Step 2: Watch for limits (where value changes)
Many plans have yearly caps, per-visit limits, or percentage-based reimbursement. These details decide whether a plan will cover a meaningful amount or only a small portion of your actual costs.
Step 3: Check policy rules before buying
Look for waiting periods, exclusions, and any restrictions tied to pre-existing conditions. These rules matter most when you’re ready to make a claim, so it’s better to understand them upfront.
Step 4: Compare value, not just monthly cost
When the benefit levels are too low, a cheaper plan may look like a good deal. However, when you use your medicines, dental care, or other health services a lot, a slightly higher premium may be worth it.
Step 5: Match the plan to your stage of life
Coverage needs change. A younger buyer may focus on dental and vision. Someone with a family might care more about prescriptions. Older adults often pay closer attention to drug costs and the overall claim limits.
Conclusion
Paying for health care out of pocket is common in Ontario, especially for things like prescription drugs, dental care, vision expenses, and everyday services such as physiotherapy or massage. Those costs can build up quickly over time, even when nothing serious happens.
That’s why some people should get health insurance. With the right plan, you can manage your daily expenses, avoid spending excessively, and stay on budget.
Trusted companies like Sun Life and Manulife offer good plan choices with a range of coverage levels. You should also consider Green Shield Canada and Ontario Blue Cross, especially if you want regular coverage and extras like travel protection or an easier way to get to your plan.
Still, if you’re looking at the overall mix of benefits and how simple it is to get started, PolicyMe is the best health insurance company in Ontario.
FAQs
Is private health insurance worth it in Ontario?
Yes, it can be worth it if you regularly pay for prescriptions, dental care, vision expenses, or services like physiotherapy. A good plan helps reduce out-of-pocket costs and makes health spending more predictable.
Can self-employed people get health insurance in Ontario?
Yes. Self-employed Ontario residents can buy individual health insurance plans directly from providers, even without workplace benefits. Coverage options and pricing depend on the plan and eligibility rules.
How much does private health insurance cost in Ontario?
Costs vary based on age, coverage level, and add-ons, but many individual plans in Ontario start around $50–$150 per month. Higher-tier plans with stronger drug and dental benefits can cost more.
Can you get health insurance in Ontario with no medical exam?
Yes. There are some insurers that offer plans with no medical exams or assured acceptance, which can make it easier to get coverage. However, it’s possible that these plans have lower limits, higher premiums, or waiting times before you can get some benefits.
Can you claim private health insurance premiums on your taxes in Ontario?
In many cases, yes. Private health insurance premiums may qualify as a medical expense on your income taxes, depending on the plan and who it covers. It’s still best to confirm eligibility with a tax professional.
